Audible Audio Edition
Listening Length: 14 hours and 41 minutes
Program Type: Audiobook
Version: Unabridged
Publisher: Simon & Schuster Audio
Audible.com Release Date: March 25, 2014
Whispersync for Voice: Ready
Language: English
ASIN: B00IF9IU8W
Best Sellers Rank: #37 in Books > Engineering & Transportation > Engineering > Energy Production & Extraction > Nuclear #115 in Books > Audible Audiobooks > Science > Physics #149 in Books > Science & Math > Physics > Nuclear Physics
Craig Nelsonâs âThe Age of Radianceâ offers a survey of nuclear energy from Henri Becquerel through the recent accident at Fukushima, and, overall, does a respectable job. As a physicist, I am familiar with the science involved with this material. I found its coverage of the personalities involved to be engaging, and intended to go through the entire volume. However, I soon noticed that it contains numerous small errors, especially in the sections that dealt with my own area of expertise, the Manhattan Project; I finally gave up about half-way through, and this is why I give this book a two-star rating.Here is a partial list of corrections: In a discussion of a memo from Vannevar Bush to President Roosevelt (p. 146), FDR is quoted as writing âTime is very much of the essence,â whereas the actual wording is âI think the whole thing should be pushed not only in regard to development, but also with due regard to time. This is very much of the essence.â Page 147 implies that a group of scientists chose General Groves to lead the Project, an assertion I have never come across in my own research. Los Alamos had 6000 residents, but only about 2500 employees (150). No credible source ever refers to Einstein having consulted at Los Alamos (153); his forte was not nuclear physics and Groves would have considered him too great a security risk. Construction on the K-25 diffusion plant did not begun until 1943, and was not finished until well into 1945 (161). A discussion at the bottom of p. 161 confusingly mixes the discovery of plutonium and uranium separation techniques in the same paragraph. A description of the S-50 liquid-diffusion plant reverses the order of heated and cooled pipes (163). On page 166, the assertion that the Hiroshima bomb âwent supercritical for less than a secondâ is strictly true, but the actual order of magnitude is only about a microsecond. Otto Hahn does not have an element named after him (190), and David Hawkins was a philosopher, not a physicist (192). A paragraph on p. 197 confusingly garbles the roles of the Jumbo containment vessel and sealing the windows of the McDonald ranch house to reduce dust during bomb assembly(!); âsearching lightâ on p. 202 is probably supposed to be âsearing lightâ; William Parsons is misidentified as the bombardier of the Enola Gay (212); Mitsubishi Heavy Industries was in Nagasaki, not Hiroshima (212); and the name of Enola Gayâs bombardier, Tom Ferebee, is mis-spelt as Farraby (212). Also, are descriptions such Wilhelm Roentgen having âunruly beard and hair, wild and untamedâ (13), or the Fat Man bomb as âgrungy and cobbled togetherâ (197), or Edward Teller âWith a face like an abdominal muscle foreshadowed by a prow of beetle brows ...â (157) really necessary? Mr. Nelson is an experienced writer who should be above such characterizations. Individually, the above points are each minor, but they make me wonder how carefully this book was researched. These are not arcane points, but rather relate to material that has been reviewed many times by scientists and historians and which can now be researched with a few minutes of online effort. Readers who seek surveys of the history of nuclear physics, radioactivity, and the development of nuclear weapons have many other more carefully-prepared volumes from which to choose.
Author Craig Nelson does a credible job of explaining the history and science of the atomic bomb, also covering a lot of politics. On the other hand, Nelson makes extensive use of quotes, particularly pertaining to Marie Curie and Paul Langevin that quickly become tiresome. Nelson does an excellent job of covering post-war nuclear issues such as the Cuban missile crisis and atomic power generation. On the latter, however, he did not cover enough science. From a science point of view, Making of the Atomic Bomb by Richard Rhodes is a better book but Nelsonâs book brings us up to the present day. Even though there is a lot of overlap between Age of Radiance and Making of the Atomic Bomb, I recommend both books for those more interested in the science of the atomic bomb and The Age of Radiance alone for those who want a little less science but more information about the situation today.
Okay, I admit it. I made a big mistake when I checked "The Age of Radiance" out of the public library. I didn't even look at the author's name on the cover when I spotted the volume on the New Books shelf. I just grabbed it and headed for the self-checkout scanner. In my defense, I was in a bit of a hurry.Had I noticed the author was the same one who gave us the memorably atrocious "Rocket Men," I would never have checked it out. But I didn't realize that until I started to read it. Since I had the book in hand then, so to speak, I figured I'd start into it anyway. I thought that perhaps Mr. Nelson did a better job explaining nuclear technology than he did Project Apollo.Unfortunately, he didn't. By the time I read Chapter 1--FIVE pages--my mind was reeling from his bizarre phraseology, botched descriptions of technical concepts and absurd uses of terminology that, to me, indicate he is as ignorant about nuclear matters as he is about spaceflight. I skimmed ahead and read a few sections about topics with which I am reasonably familiar, such as the implosion technique. He gets those wrong, too--not totally, perhaps, but enough to reveal that he does not really know much about the subject he's trying to write about."The Age of Radiance" is similar to "Rocket Men" in that Mr. Nelson relies VERY heavily on extensive quotes from other published sources. That's not necessarily bad in itself. But he clearly lacks the relevant knowledge to tie such quotes together or to place the events they describe in the proper historical context. At best, "The Age of Radiance" is a disconnected series of oral history interviews without a technically and historically accurate unifying narrative. I continue to wonder why authors such as Mr. Nelson don't write books on subjects they know about rather than on subjects that just reveal their ignorance.Some reviewers have said that Mr. Nelson writes very well. I agree--his style is lucid, fast paced and easy to read. But when an author gets so many of the basic facts of the story wrong, it's not worth reading, regardless of how well it's written. "Rocket Men" wasn't, and, based on my quick scan of it, neither is "The Age of Radiance."
The Age of Radiance: The Epic Rise and Dramatic Fall of the Atomic Era Atomic Physics (Oxford Master Series in Atomic, Optical and Laser Physics) Goddesses Never Age: The Secret Prescription for Radiance, Vitality, and Well-Being Star Wars Epic Collection: Rise of the Sith Vol. 1 (Epic Collection: Star Wars) Atoms and Molecules Interacting with Light: Atomic Physics for the Laser Era The Winter Fortress: The Epic Mission to Sabotage Hitler's Atomic Bomb That's Not How We Do It Here!: A Story about How Organizations Rise and Fall--and Can Rise Again King of Capital: The Remarkable Rise, Fall, and Rise Again of Steve Schwarzman and Blackstone Words of Radiance: The Stormlight Archive, Book 2 The Diamond in Your Pocket: Discovering Your True Radiance American Queen: The Rise and Fall of Kate Chase Sprague--Civil War "Belle of the North" and Gilded Age Woman of Scandal Battletech Era Report 3062 (Clan Invasion Era Sourcebooks) Global Supply Chains: Evaluating Regions on an EPIC Framework - Economy, Politics, Infrastructure, and Competence: "EPIC" Structure - Economy, Politics, Infrastructure, and Competence Star Wars Legends Epic Collection: The Old Republic Volume 1 (Epic Collection: Star Wars Legends) Star Wars Legends Epic Collection: The New Republic Volume 1 (Epic Collection: Star Wars) The Wobblies in Their Heyday: The Rise and Destruction of the IWW During the WWI Era Gandhi & Churchill: The Epic Rivalry that Destroyed an Empire and Forged Our Age Epic Survival: Extreme Adventure, Stone Age Wisdom, and Lessons in Living from a Modern Hunter-Gatherer The Aviators: Eddie Rickenbacker, Jimmy Doolittle, Charles Lindbergh, and the Epic Age of Flight And Their Children After Them: The Legacy of Let Us Now Praise Famous Men: James Agee, Walker Evans, and the Rise and Fall of Cotton in the South