Series: The Clash of Eagles Trilogy (Book 2)
Hardcover: 576 pages
Publisher: Del Rey (March 22, 2016)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0804177244
ISBN-13: 978-0804177245
Product Dimensions: 6.6 x 1.7 x 9.5 inches
Shipping Weight: 1.6 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.3 out of 5 stars See all reviews (58 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #531,358 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #212 in Books > Science Fiction & Fantasy > Fantasy > Myths & Legends > Greek & Roman #1228 in Books > Literature & Fiction > Genre Fiction > Historical > Alternate History #2087 in Books > Literature & Fiction > Action & Adventure > Fantasy
UPDATE 20 JANUARY 2016 Re: SpoilersToo many of the reviews of the first book in this series, including the highest rated review, give up one of the major surprising premises of this series. Yes, it may be a stupid premise, it may be a cool premise (I weigh in on "cool"), but I find it unforgivable when a reviewer spoils the surprise. The reader neither gets the opportunity to guffaw and yell "THAT'S STUPID!!!" nor discover something excellent about the plot. Giving away the premise is like reviewing the new Star Wars Movie, The Force Awakens, and complaining about the death of a certain character by giving their name.ORIGINAL REVIEW:This is definitely one of those "if you didn't read the first book, don't bother starting here" works. I do highly recommend author Alan Smale's first book in this series, Clash of Eagles: The Clash of Eagles Trilogy Book I. If you have read the first in the series, this is the typical lull before the storm volume typical of trilogies. There is a lot more character development and exposition about the Hesperian (New World) societies than in the first book.Struggling not to give up any spoilers (including a really big one if you haven't read Clash of Eagles), the main difference between the first and second books is that the first one has a lot more large scale action. Smales is excellent with his battle scenes, and if I have any complaint about the series it's that there aren't enough such scenes. One of the fun things about alternate histories are the "what ifs" involving different historical technologies that never encountered each other. You do get that in these books where there are scenes where a Roman short sword (gladius) goes up against a native american chert war club. But Smales is much more fun when he's describing larger battles where tactics designed for specific weaponry is explored.Having now read the first two legs of the triology, I can say that these are a lot of fun. Smales' research really brings the different native american societies to life. He unabashedly focuses on the native american groups, primarily through his Roman protagonist (think A Roman Praetorian Dances with Wolves). I'm looking forward to, and hoping, that the final book in the trilogy will once again let us inside Roman military society.In the end, fun.
I really enjoyed "Clash of Eagles" - it was a fresh look at the alt. history trope of a Roman Empire that never fell, set in an America quite different from the one we know. Author Alan Smale continues the story in the second book int he trilogy, Eagle In Exile." Much of what made the first book excellent is still present: the informed speculation on the mysterious Cahokia and their society, the accurate depiction of Roman mores and military strategy, and the characterization of a wide variety of Roman and native characters. Unfortunately, this book suffers from the common problem for many second acts in trilogies, that is seems to be a bridge between the fresh first book and the anticipated major clash and settling of accounts likely forthcoming in book three. Parts of the story drag a bit, and the stakes do not seem as high as they were in book 1 (or will be in book 3). That criticism aside, it is still an enjoyable read and a must for anyone who liked the first book. However, if you are new to the series, read book 1 first and get a taste before moving on to "Exile"
I liked the concept as soon as I read the summary of the book. I think author Alan Smale really had a brainstorm in choosing an alternate history in which Rome finds it's way west to the New World (almost as good would have been Rome going east and contacting China).I like alternate history done right. It can show us the world that could have been if not for one or a few different decisions or rolls of the dice. That's always a good discussion and worthy of exploration. The other thing is that it must be entertaining. Otherwise it's just something else I read because I have to.I like the way the author presents the Amerindians as what they were, neither making them "peaceful and peace-loving people" who are invaded by evil, white men, blah, blah, blah. Nor are they presented as mindless savages. Instead, the Amerindians are portrayed as people of their own time and place who are capable of sophisticated thought and organization but have the same capacity for war and cruelty as everyone else. The author's dialogue is also quite good.There are some good things here and I like both alternate history and fantasy - but, not both at the same time. I found Amerindians flying hang-gliders and hot-air balloons really silly. I don't do spoilers, so I'm not going to go any further on some of the more fantasy aspects, but I really didn't like that.The book itself really dragged and developed slowly - especially in the beginning. If you are an action-adventure fan, you're going to be in this a long time before you get any. This was another aspect of the book I didn't like. It was more character-based fiction where everyone's "feelings" are paramount and who had difficulty potty training and were scarred forever by it, etc. I wanted it to be a faster-moving and more action-oriented read and it wasn't.There were some positives in this work, but not enough for the alt-history or action-adventure fan.
Eagle in Exile: The Clash of Eagles Trilogy Book II Inside a Bald Eagle's Nest: A Photographic Journey Through the American Bald Eagle Nesting Season The Eagle (The Roman Britain Trilogy Book 1) Secret of Light: An Eagle Glen Trilogy Book Heaven and Hell: My Life in the Eagles (1974-2001) National Geographic Eagles 2017 Wall Calendar North American Wildlife Patterns for the Scroll Saw: 61 Captivating Designs for Moose, Bear, Eagles, Deer and More With Wings Like Eagles: A History of the Battle of Britain A Sky Without Eagles Colorado Wings: A Wing and a Prayer/Wings Like Eagles/Wings of the Dawn/A Gift of Wings (Inspirational Romance Collection) Badges, Bears, and Eagles: The True Life Adventures of a California Fish and Game Warden Alaska's Magnificent Eagles (Alaska Geographic,) Sound Man: A Life Recording Hits With the Rolling Stones, the Who, Led Zeppelin, the Eagles, Eric Clapton, the Faces... The Music of Eagles Made Easy for Guitar: Includes Their Greatest Hits (The Music of... Made Easy for Guitar Series) Eagles: The Very Best Of (Authentic Guitar-Tab Edition) Tom Clancy's Op-Center: War of Eagles The Eagles Talon / Iron Corpses (The Horus Heresy) A Clash of Kings: A Song of Ice and Fire, Book 2 Pagan in Exile: Book Two of the Pagan Chronicles A Clash of Kings (HBO Tie-in Edition): A Song of Ice and Fire: Book Two